Operations & Reporting, 8 min read

Collision repair touch time vs cycle time: how to measure both, car by car and store by store

In collision repair, cycle time is how long the car is in your care, keys to keys, in days. Touch time is how many labor hours get worked on it for each of those days: labor hours divided by days in the shop. To measure them properly, log keys-in and keys-out for every repair order, record the hours flagged on the RO, and, if you can, the hours someone was actually working on the car in the bay, then compare the two by car and by store.

Most shops have a cycle time number because their estimating or management system calculates it. Fewer have a touch time number they trust, because it's usually worked out from flagged hours, which tell you what was billed, not what happened in the stall. This guide gives you the formulas, a worksheet you can copy, a worked example, and a way to compare shops if you run more than one.

Quick answer

  • Cycle time (keys to keys) = keys-out date and time − keys-in date and time, in days, weekends included.
  • Touch time = labor hours ÷ days in shop, in hours per day.
  • Measure touch time two ways: from flagged hours on the RO, and from hours a tech was actually seen working the car.
  • Log why the car waited: parts, approval or supplement, sublet, no tech free.
  • Compare stores on the same definitions, with the waiting reasons next to the numbers.

What is the difference between touch time and cycle time?

Cycle time is measured on the calendar. FenderBender's profile of one Fix Auto shop described it as "measured keys to keys, including weekends," and touch time as "the number of labor hours we average on each job on a per-day basis" (FenderBender). Another FenderBender piece quotes a CCC Information Services definition of touch time as "the hours a technician or estimator spends on the vehicle" (FenderBender, 2018).

The two are linked. If labor hours on a job stay the same, every day the car sits waiting pushes cycle time up and touch time down. That's why insurers and DRP scorecards watch both: a long cycle time with low touch time means the car spent most of its stay parked.

MetricFormulaUnitWhat moves it
Cycle time (keys to keys)Keys out − keys inDaysParts delays, approvals, sublet, scheduling, capacity
Touch timeLabor hours ÷ days in shopHours per daySame as cycle time, plus how fast work gets done once started
Flagged touch timeFlagged hours on the RO ÷ days in shopHours per dayHours billed
Seen touch timeHours a tech was seen working the car ÷ days in shopHours per dayHours actually worked in the stall

How do you measure touch time in a body shop?

Use the same steps for every RO at every store.

  1. Record keys-in and keys-out with a date and time, not just a date. Use the moment the customer hands over the keys and the moment they get them back.
  2. Work out days in shop: hours between keys-in and keys-out, divided by 24, to one decimal. Weekends count.
  3. Pull flagged hours from the RO (body, refinish, mechanical, frame). Leave out sublet hours, which are logged separately.
  4. Get seen work hours if you can: the time a tech was actually working the car, from bay cameras or a job clock that techs punch on and off per RO.
  5. Log each wait with a reason and how long it lasted: parts, approval or supplement, sublet, no tech free, customer.
  6. Calculate both touch times (flagged and seen) and look at the gap.

Do this for two to four weeks before acting on it. A single car tells you little. Twenty cars per store tell you a lot.

Worksheet: one row per repair order

Copy this into a spreadsheet. Same columns at every store.

ROStoreKeys inKeys outDays in shopFlagged hoursSeen work hoursFlagged touch timeSeen touch timeWaits (reason, days)

Worked example

Made-up numbers, not real store data. Four repair orders from one store.

ROKeys inKeys outDays in shopFlagged hoursSeen work hoursFlagged touch timeSeen touch timeWaits
AMon 8:00amFri 4:00pm4.318.013.54.23.1Parts 1.5 days
BTue 9:00amNext Tue 3:00pm7.322.015.03.02.1Supplement approval 2 days, parts 1 day
CWed 10:00amThu 4:00pm1.36.56.05.04.6None
DMon 8:00amNext Thu 5:00pm10.431.024.03.02.3Sublet frame 2 days, parts 3 days
Store23.377.558.53.32.5

The store-level touch time is total hours divided by total days (77.5 ÷ 23.3 and 58.5 ÷ 23.3), not an average of the four rows, so a short job doesn't count the same as a long one.

What it shows: RO D spent 5 of its 10.4 days waiting on parts and a sublet. RO B lost 2 days to a supplement approval. Those waits, not slow techs, are what drag this store's touch time down. RO C is the shape you want: in, worked, out.

How do you read the gap between flagged and seen hours?

Expect a gap. Under flat-rate pay, a skilled tech often beats book time, so flagged hours run higher than hours worked. That's a good thing, and it's why the gap alone isn't a problem. What to look at:

  • A gap that's much bigger at one store than the others, on similar work.
  • A gap concentrated on one operation, like refinish or a particular kind of supplement.
  • Seen hours near zero on a day the car was "in production." The car may have been parked.
  • A gap that changes suddenly when a tech, estimator or manager changes.

Treat each of these as a reason to recheck a few ROs with the team, not as proof of anything. Sometimes the answer is a booth or frame machine the camera can't see, or a tech who worked the car in a different stall.

How do you compare touch time and cycle time across stores?

Use the same definitions at every store, then put the numbers side by side with the main waiting reason.

Made-up numbers, not real store data. Four weeks, three stores.

StoreAvg cycle time (days)Flagged touch timeSeen touch timeGap (flagged vs seen)Top waiting reason
16.83.42.915%Parts
29.13.62.239%Approvals and supplements
37.42.82.67%Sublet

On flagged hours alone, store 2 looks like the most productive shop. Seen hours and cycle time tell a different story: cars stay longest there, and much of that time nobody is working them. The top waiting reason points at the fix: how fast supplements get written and approved, not how fast techs work. Store 3's flagged touch time is lowest, but its gap is small, so its numbers are the most believable, and its lever is sublet scheduling.

If you already have a multi-location dashboard, this is a good table to add to it. The same idea of comparing what was billed with what happened in the bay is behind our guide to unbilled work in auto repair, and the difference between efficiency and productivity is covered in technician efficiency vs productivity.

What is a good touch time for a collision shop?

There's no current, sourced national benchmark we'd stand behind. The figures that show up in trade articles are old and measured in different ways. A 2019 FenderBender column cited "a national average of 4.0 hours per day for touch time and 6 days for cycle time" without naming where it came from (FenderBender, 2019). Your insurers' scorecards and your own stores are better references: measure your own baseline per store for a month, then set targets from that.

Can cameras measure touch time?

Yes, with limits. Fixed cameras over the stalls can show when a car is in a stall and when someone is working on it, and software can turn that into hours per car and match them to the RO. It works best where each stall has a clear view. It's weaker in paint booths, on frame machines with poor sightlines, and when a car moves between stalls a lot, so check a sample of clips against the numbers in the first weeks. Most shops can start with the cameras they already have.

How Trilix fits

We build this on the cameras you already have. Each car gets keys-in to keys-out, time in each stall and time someone was seen working it, matched to its repair order, with wait time sorted by reason. The results land on one owner dashboard every morning, store by store: cycle time, both touch times, the gap, and the cars that have sat longest. Nothing changes in your estimating or management system.

Want touch time and cycle time by store without a clipboard?

We'll look at your cameras and your repair orders and show you what the numbers would look like at each location.

Before you sign anything, you’ll speak with businesses we already work with. No pitch deck, no pressure. If it’s not a fit, we’ll tell you.

FAQ

Something else on your mind? Ask us directly or call 416-262-2723.

How do you calculate cycle time in collision repair?

Subtract the keys-in date and time from the keys-out date and time, and express it in days, weekends included. Some shops also track a "production" cycle time that starts when parts and approval are in place; if you do, report it separately and keep keys to keys as the main number.

How do you calculate touch time?

Divide labor hours on the job by days in the shop. For example, 20 labor hours over 5 days is 4 hours per day. Calculate it from flagged hours and, if you can, from hours actually worked, and compare the two.

Why is my touch time low when my techs are busy?

Usually because cars sit between steps: waiting on parts, supplement approvals or sublet. Busy techs can still mean low touch time per car if each car spends most of its days parked. Log the waits by reason to see which one is costing you.

Is touch time the same as technician efficiency?

No. Efficiency compares flagged hours with hours a tech clocked. Touch time is about the car: how many hours it gets worked for each day it's in your care.

Do I need new cameras to measure touch time?

Usually not. Most shops already have cameras covering the stalls. What matters is the angle and whether each stall is clearly visible.

Who should see touch time and cycle time numbers?

The owner, each store manager and the production manager, on the same definitions. Share the waiting reasons with the people who can fix them: parts, estimating and scheduling.